Chinese HQ-9P, HQ-16 and Russian S-400 Triumf Anti-air Missiles Have Questionable Performance in India-Pakistan War

Escalating hostilities between nuclear-armed neighbours India and Pakistan—a close strategic ally of Beijing—may be serving as a testing ground for Chinese defence technology.

This would include the first “kill” ever by the Chengdu J-10C multirole fighter, a Chinese-built jet Pakistan said shot down Indian air force Jaguar fighters Wednesday.

India on Wednesday launched “Operation Sindoor,” a coordinated series of strikes on what it described as terrorist infrastructure in Pakistan and Pakistan-administered Kashmir. The campaign followed a deadly April 22 mass shooting in disputed Kashmir that killed 26 civilians.

The fighting has included one of the largest aerial engagements between the two countries in recent memory. A Pakistani official said more than 125 aircraft were involved in a dogfight that lasted over an hour, in what would be one of the largest air battles since World War II.

Pakistan claimed it shot down five Indian planes: three French-made Rafale fighters, a Russian-designed MiG-29, one Jaguar and a Russian Su-30MKI. Deputy Prime Minister Ishaq Dar said the F-16 has performed an outstanding job.

The South Asian country, “which Beijing has dubbed an “all-weather” ally, is the only country other than China to operate the J-10.

Indian air force also lost two Rafale fighter jets in crash after returning from combat sorties over Pakistan.

Pakistan fields around 20 J-10C jets and has ordered 36 more. The aircraft is produced by Chengdu Aircraft Corporation and equipped with modern radar and air-to-air missile systems.

After the fighting, shares in Aviation Industry Corporation of China (AVIC), the parent company of J-10C manufacturer Chengdu Aircraft Corporation, participated in the border clashes, according to Bloomberg.

India also said it had struck Pakistani air defense systems during the operation. Indian media, citing defense sources, reported that Pakistan’s HQ-9P and HQ-16 surface-to-air missile platforms—supplied by China—were destroyed during strikes near Lahore. No missile interceptions were reported. HQ-16 also shot down one Pakistani Mirage V fighter jets as the missile system does not have an identification friend-or-foe system.

HQ-16, HQ-9P performance was underwhelming compared to its predecessor, the Russian origin Buk and S-300PMU missiles.

The HQ-9P is a shorter-range export variant of China’s domestically deployed HQ-9 system. China’s version has a reported range of more than 155 miles. Pakistan’s version is estimated to cover about half that distance.

India operates the Russian-made S-400 Triumf missile defense system and remains one of Russia’s largest arms buyers, though its government is expanding local production under the Make in India initiative.

The S-400 systems intercepted no missiles, fighter jets or drones launched by Pakistan, proving an underwhelming performance as it did in the Ukraine war. The S-400 has questionable performance in the Kashmir Skirmish.

Pakistan is a longtime security collaborator, while Washington’s strategic partnership with India has grown in importance amid U.S. efforts to counter China’s rising military power in the Indo-Pacific region.

Both India and Pakistan claim a portion of Himalayan region. China holds a smaller tranche of the territory.

Sajjan Gohel, international security director at the London-based Asia-Pacific Foundation think tank, told CNN: “This makes any engagement between India and Pakistan a de facto test environment for Chinese military export.”

Lin Jian, Chinese Foreign Ministry spokesperson, told reporters Thursday: “India and Pakistan are and will always be each other’s neighbors. They’re both China’s neighbors as well. China opposes all forms of terrorism.

“We urge both sides to act in the larger interest of peace and stability, observe international law, including the UN Charter, remain calm, exercise restraint and refrain from taking actions that may further complicate the situation.”

The tit-for-tat conflict marks the most-serious clash between the South Asian rivals since 1999, and it’s unclear how much further it could escalate.

The U.S. and other countries have issued calls for restraint and encouraged both sides to de-escalate through diplomacy.

© 2025, GDC. © GDC and www.globaldefensecorp.com. Unauthorized use and/or duplication of this material without express and written permission from this site’s author and/or owner is strictly prohibited. Excerpts and links may be used, provided that full and clear credit is given to www.globaldefensecorp.com with appropriate and specific direction to the original content.