Finland’s HX Programme’s Fighter Jet Comparison

Lockheed Martin F-35A Lightning II (Photo Courtesy Lockheed Martin)

Finland’s HX fighter programme to replace the Finnish Air Force’s F/A-18 C/D Hornet has entered its evaluation phase with the country set to evaluate entrants from Airbus, Boeing, Dassault Aviation, Lockheed Martin and Saab ahead of awarding a contract in late 2021. Finland’s air force currently operates 62 legacy F/A-18 Hornets. The government received proposals from four countries, including the United States, Sweden, France and Britain.

Colonel Keränen, head of the HX Programme, outlining how the programme is continuing. Source corporalfrisk.com

Helsinki plans to select a winner during 2021, with the chosen type to replace its air force’s F/A-18C/D combat aircraft from around 2025. Operations with its legacy Hornets are due to conclude by 2030.

Read More Saab send Gripen E and GlobalEye to Finland for a lucrative £10 billion Contract

The Hornets are set to start being phased out starting in 2025 and the competition recently entered crunch phase, with the Finnish Ministry of Defence now starting to evaluate the competitors’ entrants against their claims ahead of a contract decision late next year. The new jets will enter service as the old Hornets are phased out and will be delivered through till 2030.

Read More Lockheed Martin begins production of F-35 for Royal Danish Air Force

Finland kicked off its quest for a new fighter jet in 2015 when then Prime Minister Sipilä’s office launched the programme to find a replacement for the ageing fleet of F/A-18 C/D Hornets. This triggered the preliminary stages of the programme, which recommended that the Finnish Armed Forces look to acquire a fleet of multi-role fighter jets.

Read More BAE Systems AN/ASQ-239 Advanced Electronic Warfare System

The Finnish operating environment is different to other countries but comparable to Canada, Norway and Sweden. Following the Typhoon’s participation ( 9-17 January), the programme’s other candidates will undergo vigorous evaluation process. These are the Dassault Rafale (20-28 January), Saab Gripen E (29 January-6 February), Lockheed Martin F-35A (7-17 February) and Boeing’s F/A-18E/F Super Hornet (18-26 February).

Boeing F/A-18 Super Hornet

Boeing told in a press release that as a follow-up to the Hornet, the infrastructure to support the Finnish Air Force in flying the Super Hornet essentially already exists. With many existing industry partners in Finland already up and running it would be possible to perform assembly of the aircraft or components in the country. Boeing emphasized this easy switch, saying: “You could have a Hornet flying today and a Super Hornet flying tomorrow.”

Super Hornet

The Super Hornet is a mainstay of the US Navy’s aerial power, with Boeing saying the Block III Super Hornet can engage threats across air, land and sea.
Boeing explained: “The F/A-18 Super Hornet is the world’s most proven and affordable multi-role fighter and will continue to evolve with the development of the next-generation Block III Super Hornet.

Read More Germany Selects Boeing F/A-18 Super Hornet to Replace Aging Tornado

“The Block III configuration adds capability upgrades that include enhanced network capability and processor, longer range, reduced radar signature, advanced cockpit system, enhanced communications system, as well as the life of the airframe being extended from 6,000 hours to 10,000 hours.”

This history of providing the legacy fleet of Hornets means a large amount of the infrastructure needed to support a fleet of Super Hornets is already in place, with Boeing estimating that around 60% of existing Hornet tooling can be used to support the newer aircraft, increasing cost savings of the programme.

Read More Boeing F/A-18 Semi-Stealth Advanced Super Hornet

Boeing added: “Ultimately, its entirely new airframe, proven capabilities, low-risk and known, affordable acquisition price, low documented life cycle costs, and guaranteed delivery schedule, make Super Hornet ideally suited to meet Finland’s fighter aircraft requirement.”

Dassault Rafale

Unlike the rest of the pack, Dassault has been somewhat muted in its decision to offer the Rafale to the Finnish Air Force for their HX programme. This week two aircraft from the French Air Force arrived in the country for its turn at evaluations in the cold.

Rafale

The aircraft is the main fighter of the French Air Force and is also used by several foreign customers including India, Egypt and Qatar. The aircraft comes in a number of variants including a carrier fighter. Finland has been offered the Rafale C aircraft; a twin-seater Rafale B is also available which can be used for training and more intensive missions.

Read More Dassault Rafale: A True Omnirole Combat Aircraft

According to Finnish media, Dassault has offered Finland the ability to operate the aircraft independently from France with the potential for the airframes to be assembled in the country if so desired.

Read More Why Dassault Rafale is a Versatile Aircraft and formidable foe?

Dassault describes the aircraft on its website as “the right answer to the capability approach selected by an increasing number of governments,” adding that the Rafale offers the ability to “carry out the widest range of roles with the smallest number of aircraft.”

Read More The RCAF comes full circle turn: Lockheed Martin F-35 firming as favorite for Canada’s future fighter capability project (FFCP)

Dassault describes the fighter jet as ‘omnirole’ rather than multi-role saying that it the Rafale is: “relevant against both traditional and asymmetrical threats, it addresses the emerging needs of the armed forces in a changing geopolitical context, and it remains at the forefront of technical innovation.”

Lockheed Martin F-35A

Lockheed Martin makes its thoughts clear on its dedicated F-35 site describing the F-35A Joint Strike Fighter as the ‘best choice for Finland’ citing the fighter’s advanced features and ever-decreasing price tag as benefits for the Finnish Armed Forces.

Read More   NRIET Type 1475 (KLJ-5) AESA Radar For J-20 Fighters
Lockheed Martin F-35A

Lockheed Martin says that it will support Finnish security of supply for the fighter by establishing maintenance facilities in the country, and by maintaining an adequate level of ‘materiel stock in country’.

Read More Over-hyped S-400 and S-300 Surface-to-air Missile failed to Detect F-35I Adir

Lockheed also touts the large international user base of the F-35 as a potential advantage of the fighter, increasing interoperability with several of Finland’s allies both in Europe and across the world. The F-35 will ‘help Finland ensure its national security and its ability for building partnerships and interoperability for decades to come,’ according to Lockheed.

Read More Poland signs a deal to buy Lockheed Martin F-35 at an estimated cost of $4.6 billion

The company says use of the aircraft within Europe is a means to increase partnership opportunities and cost-sharing ability, which would also help to reduce through-life costs. The aircraft is set to operate long into this century, with its service life projected through to 2070.

Read More The Lockheed Martin F-35 Lightning II Stealth 5th Generation Fighter jet

Lockheed first confirmed its interest in the HX programme at Paris Air Show 2019, and the F-35 is set to undergo evaluation trials 7 – 17 February.

Saab Gripen

Describing why the aircraft is a good fit for the Finnish Armed Forces, Saab Gripen campaign director for Finland Magnus Skogberg told Air Force Technology: “Gripen E/F features the latest available technology for the continuously changing and very challenging operational environment.

Brazilian Air Force Gripen E

“Gripen has been designed from the start for the challenging operations and threat scenarios very similar to those in Finland. It is built for road-base operations, harsh climate and easy maintenance by conscript mechanics.”

The Gripen has undergone evaluation on January 2020 and will face the same tests as its competition. A number of countries already use the Gripen, including Sweden and Hungary, as well as other customers across the world.

Read More Saab Gripen E/F: The Smart Fighter Jet AKA “Sukhoi Killer”

Saab is offering the E/F variant which features an advanced electronic warfare package designed to detect threats before they locate the aircraft.

Skogberg added: “In addition to a substantial weapon and sensor package as well as the necessary equipment and associated services needed for operating the system, our offer to Finland includes also the world’s most advanced AEW&C system GlobalEye, which brings Finnish situational awareness to a whole new, strategic level.”

Skogberg added Saab’s bid would come hand-in-hand with a number of promises to bolster Finnish industry. He said: “We offer a true industrial partnership with the aim to build extensive national capabilities in Finland for Security of Supply. Our offer includes transfer of maintenance, repair and overhaul capabilities to local industry, production of aircraft and an establishment of a Gripen and GlobalEye sustainment and development centre in Finland.”

Eurofighter Typhoon

On 10 January, the Typhoon became the first of the five possible fighters to take part in the competition’s HX challenge phase, with the aircraft’s performance being tested under the operation of UK Royal Air Force (RAF) pilots.

Eurofighter Typhoon

A key test for the Typhoon will be cold-weather testing to make sure it can handle Finnish environments and still perform to expectations.

Eurofighter Typhoon HX Challenge- press briefing

Commenting on the trials, Typhoon Chief Test Pilot Steve Formoso said: “We believe Eurofighter meets every operational requirement of the Finnish Air Force today and is already optimized to defend Finland for many decades to come. There are close to 500 Eurofighters in Europe and, through that, we have demonstrated the aircraft can operate in the most difficult and demanding of conditions.

Read More Needs Some Firepower, Have Cash: Get Eurofighter Typhoon

“For example, Eurofighter provides to the defense of the Falkland Islands from RAF Mount Pleasant in the South Atlantic, operating some 13,000km away from ‘home’ bases in the UK. On top of that, Eurofighters from across the European air force regularly undertake NATO Baltic Air Policing and over their own airspace.”

Like many of the other fighters on offer, the Typhoon has seen extensive service with European Air Forces including the German Luftwaffe, the UK Royal Air Force and the Italian Aeronautica Militare.

Read More Kuwaiti Air Force owns the most advanced variant of Eurofighter Typhoon

BAE Systems Finland Managing Director Paul Hitchcock emphasized this, telling Air Force Technology: “We believe that by choosing Eurofighter, the Finnish Air Force would not only be acquiring the most advanced multi-role aircraft on the market, and one proven in service across the globe, it would be choosing everything Finland needs to independently operate, maintain and control its own aircraft in peacetime and times of crisis.”

Side by Side Comparison

Attribute Gripen Eurofighter Rafale Super Hornet F-35
Combat Role Swing-role Multi-role Omnirole Multi-role Multi-role
Manufacturer Saab Group Eurofighter Consortium Dassault Aviation Boeing Defence Lockheed Martin
Country of Origin Sweden EU France America America
Aircraft Generation 4.5 4.5 4.5 4.5 5th Generation
Mission Air patrol, EW, Reconnaissance, Area denial, air dominance, Maritime Strike Air patrol, EW, Reconnaissance, Area denial, air dominance, Maritime Strike Air patrol, EW, Reconnaissance, Area denial, air dominance, Maritime Strike, Nuclear Deterrent Air patrol, EW, Reconnaissance, Area denial, air dominance, Maritime Strike, Nuclear Deterrent Air patrol, EW, Reconnaissance, Area denial, air dominance, Maritime Strike, Nuclear Deterrent
Weapons carried Air-to-air, air-to-ground, anti-radiation, anti-ship   Air-to-air, air-to-ground, anti-radiation, anti-ship   Air-to-air, air-to-ground, anti-radiation, anti-ship   Air-to-air, air-to-ground, anti-radiation, anti-ship   Air-to-air, air-to-ground, anti-radiation, anti-ship  
Weapon Origin EU and US EU and US EU and US US and EU US and EU
Engine GE F414-GE-39E turbofan Eurojet EJ200 turbofan Snecma M88 engines GE F414-GE-400 turbofan Pratt & Whitney F135
Speed Mach 2 Mach 2+ Mach 1.8 Mach 1.9 Mach 1.6
AESA Radar Raven ES-05 CAPTOR-E RBE2 AN/APG-79 AN/APG-81
Combat Radius 800 nm 1,500nm 1,000nm 449nm 669nm
Ferry Ranges 2200 nm 2,050nm 2,000nm 1,800nm 1,500nm
Service Ceiling 50000 feet 65,000 feet 50,000 feet 50,000 feet 50,000 feet
G limit 9 +9 +9 9 +9
BVRAAM Meteor, AIM-120C/D Meteor, AIM-120C/D Meteor, MICA AIM-120C/D AIM-120C/D
SRAAM IRIS-T, AIM-9, A-Darter (Brazil) IRIS-T, AIM-9 IRIS-T, AIM-9, MICA AIM-9X, ASRAAM (RAAF) AIM-9X, ASRAAM (RAAF)
Anti-ship RBS-15 Harpoon Exocet Harpoon Harpoon, NSM
Bombs GBU-12 Paveway II, GBU-22 Paveway III, GBU-24 Paveway III, GBU-49 Enhanced Paveway II GBU-12 Paveway II, GBU-22 Paveway III, GBU-24 Paveway III, GBU-49 Enhanced Paveway II GBU-12 Paveway II, GBU-22 Paveway III, GBU-24 Paveway III, GBU-49 Enhanced Paveway II GBU-12 Paveway II, GBU-22 Paveway III, GBU-24 Paveway III, GBU-49 Enhanced Paveway II GBU-12 Paveway II, GBU-22 Paveway III, GBU-24 Paveway III, GBU-49 Enhanced Paveway II
Cruise Missile/ Anti-radiation MBDA Storm Shadow/SCALP-EG, SLAM-ER, JSOW MBDA Storm Shadow/SCALP-EG MBDA Storm Shadow/SCALP-EG SLAM-ER, JSOW, JASSM, LRASM SLAM-ER, JSOW, JASSM, LRASM
Sensors EW Pod, IRST, Targeting Pod EW Pod, IRST, Targeting Pod EW Pod, IRST, Targeting Pod EW Pod, IRST,  Targeting Pod EW Pod, IRST,  Targeting Pod
CountermeasuresChaff, Missile Approach warning receiver, Electronic countermeasures Chaff, Missile Approach warning receiver, Electronic countermeasures Chaff, Missile Approach warning receiver, Electronic countermeasures Chaff, Missile Approach warning receiver, electronic countermeasures Chaff, Missile Approach warning receiver, electronic countermeasures
Data LinkLink 16Link 16Satellite, VHF, UHFLink 16Link 16

© 2020, GDC. © GDC and www.globaldefensecorp.com. Unauthorized use and/or duplication of this material without express and written permission from this site’s author and/or owner is strictly prohibited. Excerpts and links may be used, provided that full and clear credit is given to www.globaldefensecorp.com with appropriate and specific direction to the original content.

Be the first to comment

Leave a Reply

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.